Chicago Tuesday Asbestos Call: Eventful Call for Vogelzang Law

Chicago Tuesday Asbestos Call: Eventful Call for Vogelzang Law

0 Comments

Chicago, IL (October 30, 2018) —

The Daley Center hosts an Asbestos Call every other Tuesday, which serves as the time and place to track the progress of a lawsuit in preparation for the trial date. The Vogelzang Law blog provides bi-weekly Asbestos Call updates.

There was a heated exchange in Room 2005 at the Daley Center on Tuesday regarding the case of James Thomas, a Local 17 Chicago Insulator who passed away this year from lung cancer. Vogelzang Law recently offered to have James Thomas’ son, who is also a Local 17 Insulator, testify regarding some of the work he performed with his father which exposed them both to asbestos. Trial in the matter was initially set for November 13, 2018, but two Big Oil defendants stated that they needed more time to prepare for trial given the additional testimony.

Vogelzang Law attorneys Michael Maienza and Nicholas Vogelzang claimed that James Jr. would offer no new evidence and would simply corroborate testimony of his father’s asbestos exposure. In addition, they claimed that any defense expert’s testimony would remain unchanged and therefore, no additional time was required. The defendants vociferously disagreed in tandem, and Judge McWilliams ultimately decided that there would either be a trial continuance to provide more time for the Big Oil defendants or a trial without the testimony of James Jr. for the plaintiff.  The plaintiff secured a January 2019 trial date, and the case is now scheduled for a 12 person jury trial to begin the new year.

In another motion in the Robert Bergren mesothelioma case, an automotive defendant complained about recently tendered discovery, questioning their corporate structure as overly burdensome and a “delay tactic”. Plaintiff’s counsel stated that it was quite standard for such a large multi-billion dollar institution, and the judge allowed the discovery to proceed as scheduled.

Additionally, attorney Wyatt Berkover represented Mr. Ulrich Huemmerich, a lifelong engineer who passed away earlier this year after being diagnosed with mesothelioma. On Tuesday, Mr. Berkover brought a motion against an asbestos-containing torch cutter manufacturer that Ulrich Huemmerich was exposed to during his work atseveral steel mills throughout the country. Mr. Berkover asked for the deposition of the person most knowledgeable of the corporate structure of the company. The torch cutter insisted that plaintiff had the wrong entity and they shouldn’t be brought into the litigation. However, Attorney Berkover pointed out to the judge that the documents provided were insufficient to show the defendant’s claim of no liability and were inapposite of what could be found online regarding the company. Judge McWilliams stated that she could not get her arms around such a complex argument in the span of two minutes and requested that plaintiff submit a brief summarizing the issues. The motion was entered and continued for two weeks until the next asbestos call on November 13.

In the final development this week, Vogelzang Law attorney Michael Maienza recently took the deposition of the corporate representative of the seller of asbestos-containing building panels which mesothelioma victim Bennett Mulder used frequently and on many job sites throughout his career. In that deposition, the defendant claimed that certain correspondence regarding their asbestos fiber suppliers was privileged.  After submitting a strong legal brief and making a salient argument, the judge found in favor of the plaintiff and that the document contained no privilege. The judge ordered that the defendant turn over the correspondence and related attachments.

The Vogelzang Law team continues to advocate for families across America who have been impacted by asbestos. Mesothelioma is a rare and aggressive cancer linked to asbestos fibers, which are easily inhaled when working with asbestos materials. As a result, insulators, pipefitters, construction workers, mechanics, and more are among the most at-risk groups.

Nicholas Vogelzang

Author

Nicholas Vogelzang has tried numerous asbestos lawsuits on behalf of families stricken with mesothelioma, in both Cook County and Madison County, Illinois. During one of his first trials on behalf of Roby Whittington in 2003, Mr. Vogelzang and his team received the most significant asbestos verdict in Illinois history at $250,000,000.Since then, he has represented more than 200 families with every imaginable type of asbestos exposure throughout the country, resulting in more than 200 million in settlements and verdicts. In 2017, he represented a variety of workers diagnosed with mesothelioma. His clients included: a bricklayer from US Steel; an insulator from Hooker Chemical; a laborer from Union Carbide; a sheet metal worker from John Deere; a plastic worker from Batts Plastics; two employees from Borg Warner; and a Local 130 Chicago union plumber. Nicholas takes pride in personally getting to know each family by working with them to determine the source of the asbestos exposure.His clients for 2018 include: a sheet metal worker; a chemical engineer from Allied Chemical; a TWA airplane mechanic; the mother and husband of a Local 597 Chicago pipefitter; a residential and commercial plumber; a window glazier; a Local 17 asbestos insulator; the wife of a John Jay High School maintenance worker; a pipe fitter that worked at Bethlehem Steel and later Kroger Dairy; and two steelworkers from US Steel.Mr. Vogelzang dedicates himself to his craft, regularly appearing in court on behalf of his clients to argue motions against Fortune 500 companies and their national counsel. He continues his dedication to his clients by working with bright young associates that assist in every aspect of the litigation.

    You May Also Like

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Stack of Vogelzang Client Guides Get Your Free Mesothelioma Guide
    Get a free mesothelioma guide for you and your family! Fill Out the Form To Receive Yours In The Mail Vogelzang Law Client Guides open to various pages